We read Andy's friends' letters to him after his death. What would you say to Andy? Explain your answer.
Would you change the ending of this story? Why or why not?
When do you think Andy passed the point of no return with his struggles and internal conflict?
Would you recommend this book to someone else? Why or why not?
11 comments:
1. You are dum Andy who would do such a thing. You know your life could have been better. Also did you think about Keshia or your friends well no you did't. I hope you enjoy it were you are but down here were not as lucky. Thomas
2. No I would not change the ending it is very good ending. It is a good life story. It would also make people buy the other books to learn more about the story. It is also a difernt ending then nomral and turhtly I like that.
3. When his mom and dad did not understand his promblem. The other part is when no one could help him because his doctor was gone and he broke up with Keshia that is when he lost it.
1. I would say andy your stupid why did you kill youself!!! Thats not the way out. You didnt even think of your family. That was dumb. Your other friends saw rob died but did you see them kill them self no only you did. stupid!!
Now you will miss everything in life.
2. I would change it because if this was real i bet they would think about their family. So i would of let andy live and get though all this and when he's older he will get married to his girl and live a good life.
3. I think when he broke up with his girl. Thats when i thought it all went wrong. He had no one to talk to and he's dad dont really pay much attenion to him.
4. I would recommed this book to people. Its a good book and teaches a lesson in the story.
Well firs of all I would tell him that it was wrong of him to leave his friends to deal with robs death alone. and that it was wrong to kill himself witthout thinking about his mam, dad, brother, or Kiesha. I would also tell him that just because he is dead that his body and blood would not just dissapear. I would not change the story because if I changed onne part I could ruin the whole thing. I think that Andy went past the point of no return when Kiesha broke up with him, partialy because she was probably one of the only people that comforted him. I would reconmend this book to anyone who might be a little unstable because It might help them.
We read Andy's friends' letters to him after his death. What would you say to Andy? Explain your answer.
I would say that he is stupid for doing that.
Would you change the ending of this story? Why or why not?
I wouldn't because it would be teaching anyone who reads the book a lesson on drinking and driving.
When do you think Andy passed the point of no return with his struggles and internal conflict?
I Think it was when he and Keisha broke up.
Would you recommend this book to someone else? Why or why not?
Yes because it would tell them not to drink and drive because it can effect You and everyone around you.
We read Andy's friends' letters to him after his death. What would you say to Andy? Explain your answer.
I would say dont do it ,you have much more to achevie in life.Your family wuold be diveasated.
Would you change the ending of this story? Why or why not?
Yes I would, change the ending because why would you end the story with someone dying what to happy endings.
When do you think Andy passed the point of no return with his struggles and internal conflict?
Would you recommend this book to someone else? Why or why not?
I would recommend this to someone who is having problems and is considering suicide.
We read Andy's friends' letters to him after his death. What would you say to Andy? Explain your answer.
I would say that how did you die in the book.
Would you change the ending of this story? Why or why not?
No because the ending is sad and I liked that part.
When do you think Andy passed the point of no return with his struggles and internal conflict?
When ever his friend died in the car.
Would you recommend this book to someone else? Why or why not?
Yes I would because this is a very good book.
I would be mad because before he killed himself he should have tried to make friends or ask people how they felt about him.
yes,because its said to hear something about a real good basketball player for a high school killed him self cause anyone in his school didnt like him.
I think he passed it when he started lying to people about his feelings and how he felt in the inside of him
I wouldnt rweccommened anyone reading this book at the ending because is not good for someone to do that to themselves
We read Andy's friends' letters to him after his death. What would you say to Andy? Explain your answer. I think its wrong but maybe I dont know the pain he was feeling so it's his choice not mine.
Would you change the ending of this story? Why or why not?
No, because it was a good suprise ending.
When do you think Andy passed the point of no return with his struggles and internal conflict?
The moment Andy decided not to go to school and kill himself.
Would you recommend this book to someone else? Why or why not? I would because I think they might get hooked to the series like I did.
We read Andy's friends' letters to him after his death. What would
What would you say to Andy? Explain your answer.
Andy you need to let the past be the past and move on because you can't change the past but you can change the future.
Would you change the ending of this story? Why or why not? I would because I would like to read more about why he thought about killing himself. When do you think Andy passed the point of no return with his struggles and internal conflict?when the love of Andy's life Keisha
Would you recommend this book to someone else? Why or why not? Yes I would because it is a cliff hanger.
We read Andy's friends' letters to him after his death. What would you say to Andy? Explain your answer.
I would say Dear Andy, Why did you kill yourself.You how great friends and you could have got you a scholarship.
Would you change the ending of this story? Why or why not?
No I want change the ending because it is like a sad ending.
When do you think Andy passed the point of no return with his struggles and internal conflict?
I think when Andy didn't do his work in school,and when miss the scholarship people.
Would you recommend this book to someone else? Why or why not?
Yes I would recommend this book to my teacher Mrs.Frick because she like sad story books.
1 I woud tell him t nopt make such a stupied desision just because you have aweak heart.
2 no I would not chang the inding of the story
3 I think Andy passed the point of no return with his struggles when Kesha broke up with him
4 I would recremend this book to people how like cliff endings.
Post a Comment